complexities of the conflict

i had a meeting today with one of the directors of Peace Child Israel, an israeli organization that promotes coexistence between Israeli Jews and Arabs by means of theater. in theory, the meeting was about potential dissertation research, but over the course of the 45 minutes or so of our discussion, the conversation brought up a lot of interesting thoughts about the israeli/palestinian, israeli/arab, jewish/arab conflict.

one of the interesting things that came up was the amount of disagreement within organizations about objectives of the organization’s work, and, more broadly, about desires for the future of an israeli state. what happens when a coexistence organization, staffed by both jewish and non-jewish israelis, tries to keep its momentum going during war (as in, during the gaza war this past winter)? the cracks widen, disagreements abound, and the true complexities of peace-building in israel (note: within israel, not between israel and her neighbors) become painfully obvious. as i was told today, an israeli and palestinian state might exist side by side…but even once they do, it will take 5 generations for relations between all the citizens of this state – the state of israel – to normalize. whatever ‘normalize’ means.

it’s an interesting dilemma, especially for an organization committed to working jointly to give youth an opportunity to see a different future than the one that exists. the words i heard today were, “we agree to disagree, and it’s a starting point.” but that can only go so far, when at the end of the day the political issues have to be dealt with.

2 thoughts on “complexities of the conflict

  1. Neil

    but, while a dilemma, isn't this somewhat realistic considering the fact that these folks have been jostling each other for decades [if not millennia?]. i mean, the US frees the slaves and it takes more than 100 yrs to get nearly full freedom for their descendants and then another 40 yrs to elect a president who resembles the descendants. and, this was a movement started during the 18th century!so, while it seems that you are building a beach using a teaspoon, this pace of change might be the best we can hope for of those not of the status and abilities of "Lincoln/Gandhi/King/Rabin/__fill in your favorite here__". we all have to keep plugging away to help make the necessary, on-the-ground and day-to-day changes, no? [uh, did i get the gist of your post?]

  2. karnula

    yes, you got the gist!and yes, i agree, we need to keep moving forward, one small step at a time…but in a certain sense, i think it's more difficult to try to bring kids (or teenagers, or adults) together in an attempt to change the situation when even addressing the situation is so problematic – for this organization, anyway. not that it's not important, and super necessary work…but something about what this woman said really struck a chord with me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s